The 15 Best Mystery Games for Adults to play at your next Game Night

Imagine a night where all your guests are enjoying – their blood pumping with the excitement that they can’t contain because of the challenging mystery games that you’ve prepared for your game night. Sounds interesting right?

But, finding the perfect mystery game that will keep your guests interested is a must-have to ensure that you’ll all have fun and enjoy the night. Your mind may be boggling with questions now – should you look for a board game, murder mystery game, a guessing party game, or character description game that will keep everyone puzzled?

Hey! We got you. To help you host the best game night, we’ve rounded up The 15 Best Mystery Games for Adults that you can play on your next game night! But, before we proceed, let’s start with the basics.

What is a Mystery Game?

It’s easy to describe this kind of game, anything with mystery as the central element of the game is called a mystery game. It usually features mysterious events, clues, solving puzzles, and anything that will keep your mind hungry for more.

Mystery games are a popular choice during game nights, especially for large groups of adults since it usually requires people to work together to determine or solve the problem with the clues that they can find in the area or uncover in every step of the board game.

The Elements of a Mystery Game

  • Theme – This inspires the overall mood of the game and the players. There are tons of ideas to look for such as – casinos, TV shows, books, sports and so much more. Or if you’re planning to create your own mystery game, you can base the theme on the interests of your players.
  • Characters – They are the stars of a mystery game. From the set of characters, you’ll find the antagonist, protagonist, witnesses, and other important people included in the game. Most of the time, you can get a character description to help every player know each character better.
  • Problem – Did a character die? Did someone go missing? Do you need to open a treasure box? Those are the usual problems that players need to solve in fun mystery games. Each player has to work together or individually to find clues and solutions that will lead them to solve the mystery.
  • Clues – Some kits and mystery games come with prepacked or guided clues. Each player can use these tips or they have to answer questions that will provide the clues that will make them one step closer to the answers to the problem.
  • Props – To make every mystery game more exciting, using props and visual clues is vital. You can find kits, board games, or DIY your props for a more realistic and exciting experience.

15 Best Mystery Games for Adults

Are you ready to host the best game night with your favorite friends or people? Start listing the guests that you want to invite and get ready to choose one of the following mystery games for adults that you can consider for your next party.

Murder Mystery Games

  1. Unsolved Case Files Get ready to solve a series of cold cases with the Unsolved Case Files featuring different crimes that you can solve using over 50 documents, clues, and photos. With the online guide, anyone in your party group can be a detective solving 3 objectives that will get you closer to the killer. Some of the available cases that you can find are about the bride-to-be Harmony Ashcroft, the high school senior Jamie Banks, and more!
  2. Murder Mystery on the Night Train – Gather your best 5 to 12 players and find out who’s the killer on the train. This fun and exciting mystery game have 3 alternative endings perfect to unleash your detective skills for hours. This kit comes with an instruction booklet, welcome speech, and various name cards and clues to help the group discover the mysteries on the night train. Out of all the mystery games for adults listed, this is my favorite!
  3. There’s Been a MurderHere’s a nerve-wracking card game that your guests will love. It’s perfect for small and large groups who want to work together to discover the murderer in their midst. It features a complete guide with different cards with unique effects that they can use to catch the culprit.
  4. Killer at LargeIf you want a realistic murder mystery game, then this kit is the go-to for you. It is perfect for amateur detectives and even true crime enthusiasts who want to analyze evidence and decipher clues consistently. You can avail of one box or subscribe for an exciting new murder case that you can solve every month. Each box comes with realistic clues and details that will make you feel like you’re a real investigator.
  5. Murder Mystery Jigsaw PuzzleThis mystery game is perfect for people who love playing puzzles. This hybrid box features two puzzles with clues and a story of the incident that you have to solve. Brace yourself because this may seem like a regular puzzle but after reading the story, you’ll discover more that will wake up the detective in you. 

Large Group Mystery Games for adults

  1. Bloodwood Masquerade Murder MysteryGather your friends and get ready to explore the isolated town of Bloodworth Falls that is plagued with scandals. In 3 rounds of gameplay, your players can discover pieces of evidence and forensic reports to help you solve the case. The main game features 18 unique characters but comes with an expansion pack that can accommodate 40 unique players or expands to over 130 guests.
  2. Mafia Party GameGo back in time when the mafia is still rampant in the city. This popular game originated in 1986 by Dmitry Davidoff has many variations and can be played by 7 or up to 24 players. This detective-style murder mystery game is broken into two parts – nighttime where the Mafia is planning to murder someone innocent and daytime where each player votes to find the suspects. All you need is a deck of cards to get the party started.
  3. Mystery Tonic: One Minute MysteriesThis is the perfect mystery game if you’re looking for something that you can finish in a minute. The handy mystery kit features 80 cards with instructions to kill every quiet moment. It is portable and easy to play plus perfect for large groups who want to play a fast and interactive mystery game for adults.
  4. Murder on Baker StreetSet in the early 1900s, this game is perfect for groups of 12 to 18 people aged 14 and up. Sherlock and Watson are hosting a dinner party and you’re invited to join the fun. Review the pieces of evidence, reports, and instructions that will help you find out why the infamous Lord Blackstone helped capture the depraved serial killer on Baker Street. This game can be expanded so that 6 more players can join the mystery game.
  5. Murder Mystery at the Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party – The long name may intimidate you but this game is fun, challenging, and can be played virtually.  Up to 20 people can play this game that features a good variety of combinations for 4 to 20 people. Simply download the materials and assign the murderer in secret which the players can guess in 1 to 4 rounds.

Free Mystery Games for adults

  1. Jazz Age JeopardyThe free murder mystery game is set in a 1920s jazz club found in New York City. It can be played by up to 15 people using the free instructions, character sheets, clue cards, and voting sheets that you can download and print. This game is divided into two acts where the partygoers can have fun and enjoy the jazzy tunes of the club. The next act is the discovery of the bloody body of the victim every player should analyze and investigate to know the murderer.
  2. The Little Engine that could killFor mystery fans, this game is perfect to try. The characters are extremely detailed that’s why you can send the info to your guests in advance. It tackles the 3-day journey of a victim that didn’t survive the trip from India to Portugal. Now, it’s up to the host and the rest of the 7 passengers to discover who amongst them is the real culprit.
  3. Crack the CodesWant to encourage critical thinking and cooperative learning while playing? Then check out this free game that will help you and your friends find out the killer who committed the crime. Using the five clue cards, a suspect list card, worksheets, and instructions, the host can lead the problem-solving and code-breaking mystery game that will bring chills and excitement to everyone. Make it more challenging by adding a creepy clock or timer that will set the mood of the party.
  4. Way Out WestTake your party guests back to the 1880s with this free mystery game that occurred in a small town in the West. The game will start with murder but as the investigation continues, more and more issues will be brought up that may trigger other players to kill other characters. By the beginning of the game, each player will be given detailed background, objectives, money, and even dark secrets that will make the game more challenging and exciting.
  5. Butler Kicks the BucketYou will need exactly 15 players to play this game so better invite all your friends who are into mystery games. Before the game starts, you need to ready the character cards, name tags, fake handcuffs, and a butler costume. Assign the butler who will serve the food and will act as a key character that will mark the beginning of this exciting murder mystery game. 
best mystery games for adults